
“Life began with waking up and loving my mother’s face.” ~ George Eliot
I am a mixed bag of emotions on Mother’s Day, from pride in my own children to guilt at my failures in the mothering department; from anger at my own mother to loving and missing her, and wishing for another chance to pick up the phone and call her. I witness the selfless acts of mother-women all around me, and my heart swells to be part of this sisterhood, and am amazed for the thousandth time at the inherent strength of women, and mothers.
My mother died too soon, and by her own choice. Perhaps her depression was caused by some sort of chemical imbalance, or maybe it was just that her life was too hard. Perhaps it was an accident, even, and she didn’t really mean to pull the trigger; perhaps it was something darker, and worse, and the man she was married to shouldn’t be walking around free from prosecution. We will never really know the answers to any of this. We will question it forever, and each of us, in the quiet part of our hearts, will settle on an answer that gives us peace, and lets us remember her in the best way that we can.
I remember running to the mailbox every day after her funeral, hoping that her last act on this earth was to write each of her four children a letter. (In later conversations with my sister and brothers, it turned out they had done the same.) My hopes began to dwindle after five days or so, but I still thought it possible – I mean, sometimes mail gets delayed, right? But the mailbox remained empty. No answers there.
She had gone Christmas shopping, and there were gifts for us, and for her grandchildren, all wrapped and ready to go. In fact, I was told they were near her, and she was facing them, possibly looking at them, when she checked out. When mine was brought to me, I tore into it like a 5-year-old on Christmas morning. Not with childish joy, though. All I wanted to find in this package was a clue, or some kind of gift that had special meaning only for me; a message from my mom. But it was just a plain old set of picture frames. I cried again that day. No answers there, either.
We had heard there was a suicide note, but it had been taken into evidence by the police, and we had no idea what it said. For two months, we all imagined our occasionally-effervescent and always dramatic mother had written a novella, one that would explain everything. There was no way this woman – who cried at the Folger’s Coffee Christmas commercial – who had “Irish Eyes” emblazoned on the bugshield of her pick-up truck – who LOVED to be the life of the party, and the center of attention – well, there was just no way she would exit this play without one last fantastic monologue. But when we finally got the note…it was short, and confusing, and not at all reminiscent of the woman we had hoped her to be. No answers there, either.
There was one last chance at an explanation: her autopsy. One running theory was that she had been diagnosed with a terminal illness, and couldn’t bear it for herself, or wanted to spare all of us. (You see, when people die, no matter how they die, we do tend to give them the benefit of the doubt on things.) My sister picked up the autopsy report from the police station, and came to my house. I put on a pot of coffee, and we opened the envelope. In short, there were no answers there, either. There was no illness, no cancer. We lost her again on that day, two months after her funeral, when it punched us in the face that we would never understand what led our mother to put a gun in her own mouth and pull the trigger.
I remember reading through the medical examiner’s report, sifting through his forms and technical jargon, trying desperately to fashion a new picture of my mother that I’d never seen before. There were sections on his report for each of her major organs – their appearance, color, shape, etc., and the weight in grams of each one. I was halfway down the list – heart, lungs, liver – before it dawned on me just HOW this guy knew how much each one weighed…the process involved…cutting each part out of my mother and putting it on a scale!! Oh my God!! In a fresh burst of tears, I asked my sister if she thought he put them all back IN before her burial, and if so, did he put them back in the RIGHT WAY?? Or did he just toss them in there, like body organ soup, because – let’s face it – who would know the difference anyway? These are questions that no child, no matter how old they are, should ever have to wonder about their mother.
There was one other curious thing about the autopsy report. Apparently medical examiners have their own lingo, and after two pots of coffee and a serious crying jag, it just gets funny. When there is nothing noteworthy about a person’s body parts, they use the word, “unremarkable”. So my sister and I, recovering from the horror of the whole organ-weighing epiphany, and with not a tear left to cry between the two of us, read out loud that her lungs were “unremarkable”. Her liver was “unremarkable”. The irony – that we wanted something REMARKABLE, so we’d have an answer, goddammit – was juxtaposed against the memory of our mom’s self-deprecating sense of humor. She would have been laughing as hard as we were at that point – loud, cathartic, belly-laughs that hurt like hell – at the thought that her breasts were “unremarkable”.
It’s taken me most of the last nine years to come to this, but I believe the medical examiner was wrong about one thing. My mother’s heart was not “unremarkable.” It was maybe the most incredible thing about her. That woman LOVED. She didn’t make the best choices about who should receive her love, and that led to more terrible choices. It was for those choices that I spent most of my life being angry at her, even before she died. It was because of those choices that I chose to stay away from her, and didn’t even call to wish her a Merry Christmas two weeks before she took her own life. It was those choices that caused me a lifetime of pain, and while I can’t change the past, I can certainly try to think of her choices in a different way. In her own troubled way, she did the best she could. In her own mind, she was loving all of us, and really trying. And in the quiet part of my own heart, I have come to believe that she didn’t take her own life because she was selfish, and didn’t love us enough; I think she knew full well the pain her choices created for those of us she loved the most – her children – and her “unremarkable” heart just wasn’t strong enough to bear it all. As I said, we all have had to find an answer that gives us peace.
I’ll have more thoughts on my mother, I’m sure. And some days, I might be a little pissed off again at her. But today, on this sunny, beautiful Mother’s Day, ten years after the last time I was able to call my own mother and say hello…I can only feel happiness at the thought that, at the beginning of my life, before things got muddled and dark through the years, there was me and my mom. I can’t remember being an infant, and looking up at her face – the face that must have meant the entire universe to me – but somewhere deep inside I can remember the feeling. I know she held me, cared for me, fed me, sang to me, showed me off to friends and family…and I know I was loved by the remarkable heart of a woman. My mother.